The Hypocrisy of Tribalism in Kenyan Politics: Who Draws the Line?
The Hypocrisy of Tribalism in Kenyan Politics: Who Draws the Line?
Kenyan politics is a theatre of contradictions, where accusations of tribalism are wielded selectively to shame some communities while absolving others. This duality exposes a deeper rot: the hypocrisy of mediocrity in leadership and the weaponisation of identity to deflect accountability. Let’s unpack this through recent history.
---
2017: Isaac Rutto, Joyce Laboso, and the “Kapunji Ainet” Paradox
In 2017, Isaac Rutto, then Governor of Bomet, took a bold stand by supporting Raila Odinga, a decision seen as crossing political lines in the South Rift. His community, however, voted him out in favour of Joyce Laboso. The reason? “*Kapunji ainet” (a Kalenjin phrase loosely translating to “he decided to side with the lake”). Rutto’s support for Raila was framed as a betrayal of “our son,” the late Deputy President William Ruto’s ally, Kipchirchir. Yet, when confronted about this tribalist undertone, defenders argued it was “not tribalism” but loyalty to local leadership.
The irony? A community punished a leader for stepping outside tribal lines while denying the tribal motivation behind their backlash.
---
2027: GEMA’s “Our Son” vs. Uhuru, and the Silence on Tribalism
Fast-forward to the 2027 elections, where the GEMA community rallied behind William Ruto over their “own son,” Uhuru Kenyatta. Critics argue this was a pragmatic shift driven by economic grievances rather than tribal loyalty. Yet, when the same community previously voted overwhelmingly for “Mountain” candidates (a term symbolizing GEMA unity), their choices were rarely labelled tribalist. The narrative flipped only when they opposed a government they helped elect.
Today, as GEMA voices dissent against Ruto’s administration over soaring living costs and failed promises, they’re suddenly branded “the biggest TRIBALIST.” But where was this label when they voted across ethnic lines in 2027?
---
Double Standards: Who Gets to Be “Tribalist”?
The hypocrisy lies in the inconsistent application of the tribalist label. When a community follows its leaders to vote for “their son,” it’s framed as unity or “protecting our interests.” When another community does the same, it’s tribalism. Worse, when a community defies its leaders to vote based on shared economic struggles, they’re still accused of tribalism if their dissent aligns with ethnic demographics.
Consider this:
- Case A: A tribe votes for Candidate X because he’s “our son,” ignoring governance records.
- Case B: A tribe votes against Candidate Y (their “son”) due to poor governance, despite pressure from their elites.
Who is a tribalist here? Case A prioritizes blood over policy. Case B rejects blind loyalty. Yet, Kenyan discourse often vilifies the latter while excusing the former.
---
Tribalism as a Tool to Distract from Mediocrity
The real issue isn’t tribalism—it’s how tribal rhetoric is used to shield underperforming leaders. When a community demands accountability, they’re gaslit into defending accusations of disloyalty. Meanwhile, leaders who fail to deliver weaponize tribal identity to deflect criticism: “They’re attacking us because we’re [X tribe]!”
This cycle perpetuates mediocrity. Politicians know they can hide behind ethnic allegiances while ignoring service delivery. Citizens, in turn, internalize tribal defensiveness, stifling national progress.
---
Conclusion: Let’s Call a Spade a Spade
Tribalism exists in Kenya, but its accusation is often a smokescreen. The difference between “loyalty” and “tribalism” depends on who benefits from the narrative. Until we hold **all** communities and leaders to the same standard—judging them on governance, not blood—we’ll remain trapped in this loop of hypocrisy.
Ask yourself: Is it tribalism when a community votes with their tribe, or when they refuse to critique their tribe’s failures? The answer might reveal more about our biases than our politics.
Let’s move beyond labels. Demand better leadership. And stop letting tribal rhetoric excuse mediocrity.
---
What do you think? Share your thoughts below.
#BeyondTribalism #AccountabilityMatters
Comments
Post a Comment